At the suggestion of reader Bill, I downloaded the J. River Media Center software package and tried it out on my “music computer”. I’m still in the middle of my iPod classical music project, so I didn’t want to convert everything over to this new system, but I thought I’d “kick the tires” and play around with it a bit. Media Center has a huge set of features, so while I tested the music organizer and playback features, I didn’t even look at the TV features, CD labeler, portable player synchronizing, Download manager, among other features. This is why I am calling this a mini review.
The first impression of both the J.River web site and the Media Center software itself is one of slickness and attention to detail. There are extensive help files and FAQs on the web site, and a multitude of different modes for displaying information within the program. The appearance is attractive without too much eye candy. The default screen is similar in content and appearance to the iTunes screen. Upon opening Media Center for the first time, it asked if it could bring in media files on the computer. I agreed, and it scoured the hard drives for all media, in this case mostly music files. Basically what Media Center does is set up a database that points to wherever the files are - thus not duplicating the files the way iTunes does. Metadata (artist, pictures, etc.) are stored in the database, but can be put into the tag fields in the music files. The massive file import showed a problem, though - my FLAC files were ignored. A little study of the help files showed that only the “Monkey’s Audio” lossless compression format was supported. Given the extensive set of features and the fact that FLAC is open source makes this omission odd.
Files can be sorted and played from Media Center just like with iTunes. Unlike iTunes, Media Center preserves sample rate and bit-depth, so my 96KHz recordings played back just fine at 96KHz. (iTunes seems to downsample everything to 44.1KHz). There is lots of flexibility in creating playlists, so more sophisticated groupings of songs can easily be made.
I tried out Media Editor, a separate program that is installed at the same time as Media Center. It provides basic waveform editing with the ability to change volume, add or delete segments, etc. According to the help file, “Media Editor can open and save any of the many, many formats that are supported by Media Center “. This is somewhat misleading, since all formats are converted to .wav files while edited, then reconverted to the original format when saved, which, of course degrades files that use lossy compression. You are warned about this, though. The maneuvering and editing features are a bit clunky compared to my standard sound editor, Sony Sound Forge. There is no “interpolation” command, which is essential for taking out clicks and pops from LP recordings. So Media Editor has some use, but doesn’t replace a full-function sound editor.
On the whole, Media Center is a solid, well-designed program that does most of what I want. A fly in the ointment, though, is its product activation. It is not quite as demanding as Microsoft’s or Adobe’s activation schemes, and it allows up to ten reactivations a year, but as your system ages and eventually gets replaced, it is essential that the product activation be available forever. How many small software companies last forever? For a program that may end up holding a lifetime worth of music, this is a problem. It is also only available on the Windows platform. Since this is what I currently mainly run, this isn’t too bad for me, but I have been flirting with Mac OS X, and may want to run in a UNIX environment someday. I think I’ll hold off adopting the J. River Media Center for now, and keep looking for another, hopefully open-source program.